Let’s be honest—buying your first anal toy can feel like stepping into a whole new world. There are so many shapes, sizes, materials, and vibes (literally). And if you’re new to anal play, it’s totally normal to feel a little nervous or overwhelmed.

The good news? You don’t have to figure it all out alone.

We’ve put together a list of 5 beginner anal toys that are perfect for first-timers—whether you’re just starting to explore or looking for something to help you feel more confident. These toys are small, body-safe, and designed to make your first experience smooth, safe, and even a little exciting.

---

1. B-Vibe Novice Plug

If we had to recommend just one beginner toy, this would be it. The B-Vibe Novice Plug was made for first-timers in mind—it’s sleek, soft, and just the right size for people who are a little curious but not quite ready to dive in too deep. What makes it really stand out is the gentle vibration, which adds a whole new layer of sensation without feeling too intense.

It’s made with medical-grade silicone (aka super safe and smooth), and the flared base gives you peace of mind. Plus, it comes with a travel case and expert guides to help you feel more in control and less overwhelmed.

Why we love it: Safe, simple, and gives you just the right amount of stimulation.

 

---

2. CalExotics Booty Call Silicone Plug

This little plug is the definition of “no pressure.” It’s non-vibrating, easy to use, and great for people who just want to get familiar with the feeling of anal play. The flexible neck means it moves with your body (huge bonus for comfort), and the silky silicone finish makes it feel smooth from start to finish.

If you’ve never tried anything before and want something you can use at your own pace without any bells or whistles—this is it.

Why we love it: Straightforward, soft, and made with beginners in mind.

 

---

3. Blush Novelties Rimmer Petite

Looking for something a little playful? The Rimmer Petite is perfect if you're curious about movement and sensation but don’t want anything too intense. It’s a plug that actually rotates, giving you a unique internal massage that can feel amazing once you're warmed up.

Even better—it’s remote-controlled, so you or a partner can control the experience hands-free. Despite the fancy features, it’s still small and beginner-friendly. Think of it as your next step once you’re ready to explore a little more.

Why we love it: Adds motion and fun without losing that gentle beginner feel.

 

---

4. Doc Johnson Mood Naughty Trainer Set

Can’t decide what size you want to try? This trainer set comes with three different sizes, so you can start small and work your way up when you’re ready. It takes the pressure off having to “choose right”—you get a full range in one box.

Made of smooth silicone and shaped with comfort in mind, this is a great option if you’re planning to explore solo or with a partner. It’s like a soft intro course in anal toys—step by step, no judgment.

Why we love it: Great for learning at your own pace and figuring out what feels right.

 

---

5. Luxe Explore Mini Plug

If you’re looking for something super simple—no vibration, no rotation, just you and your curiosity—the Luxe Explore Mini is a perfect starter plug. It’s small, soft, and shaped to slide in easily without feeling too much. Great for beginners who just want to see what the hype is about without making a big investment.

It’s also great as a warm-up toy if you decide to try more advanced toys later on. Think of it like your gentle introduction to the world of backdoor pleasure.

Why we love it: Lightweight, low-commitment, and surprisingly satisfying.

 

---

Final Thoughts

There’s no one-size-fits-all when it comes to anal play—but these toys are a great place to start if you’re looking for something safe, comfortable, and beginner-approved.

Take it slow. Use lube. Breathe. And remember, you’re not doing it wrong if it takes a few tries to feel totally comfortable. This is about exploring on your own terms—with the right tools and the right support.

Want more beginner options? Check out our full Beginner Anal Toy Collection — we’re here to help you explore with confidence.